Arthur Hayes has never been one to shy away from a controversial take. The co-founder of BitMEX and current Chief Investment Officer at Maelstrom is back with another warning for the crypto industry. This time, he is pointing his finger squarely at the world’s largest stablecoin issuer.
According to Hayes, Tether is currently engaged in a risky interest rate trade that could have disastrous consequences if the market moves against them. In his view, the company is effectively betting on Federal Reserve policies in a way that could jeopardize the solvency of USDT.
The core of Hayes’ argument revolves around how Tether manages its massive reserves. To back the billions of USDT in circulation, Tether holds a variety of assets, primarily US Treasury bills. When interest rates are high, these assets generate a significant amount of yield. It sounds like a perfect business model: take dollars from users, buy Treasuries, and pocket the interest.
However, Hayes argues that this strategy is not as risk-free as it seems on the surface. He suggests that Tether is behaving less like a simple currency reserve and more like a traditional bank or a hedge fund managing duration risk. The danger lies in the volatility of bond prices.
If the Federal Reserve decides to raise rates further or if market dynamics shift rapidly, the value of the underlying bonds could drop. For a normal investment fund, a dip in asset value is just a bad quarter. For a stablecoin issuer that promises a 1-to-1 redemption for every token, a drop in asset value can be fatal.
"One misstep could nuke USDT," Hayes noted, highlighting the fragile nature of running a fractional reserve strategy without a government backstop.
Hayes points out a critical distinction between Tether and a traditional bank like JPMorgan or Bank of America. When a traditional bank faces a liquidity crunch or their bond portfolio loses value, they have access to the Federal Reserve’s discount window. They can get emergency liquidity to honor withdrawals while they wait for their assets to mature.
Tether does not have this luxury. If the market panics and users rush to redeem their USDT for dollars, Tether must sell its assets immediately to meet that demand. If they are forced to sell assets at a loss because bond prices are down, they could quickly find themselves insolvent. There is no Fed to bail them out.
In his analysis of Tether’s latest attestation report, Hayes noted concerning figures regarding their capital cushion. While Tether boasts about its excess reserves, Hayes believes the buffer might not be large enough to withstand a significant market shock. He mentioned that a decline in the value of their invested assets could wipe out their equity rapidly.
This creates a scenario where even a small miscalculation in managing interest rate risk leads to a death spiral. If the rumors of insolvency start spreading, the resulting bank run would force the very fire sale that realizes those losses.
Arthur Hayes is not necessarily calling for an immediate collapse, but he is urging caution. He often recommends that investors look for alternatives that do not carry this specific type of centralized banking risk. In previous essays, he has advocated for holding Bitcoin directly or looking into stablecoin models that do not rely on the traditional banking system to the same degree.
For the average crypto user, this serves as a stark reminder. While USDT is the lifeblood of crypto trading, it is not without its own set of risks. The stability of the peg relies entirely on the competency of Tether’s management and the cooperation of the bond market.
As the Federal Reserve continues to navigate a tricky economic environment, the ripple effects will be felt across the crypto landscape. Hayes wants to make sure everyone is watching the plumbing, not just the token prices.
.png)